Who doesn't love ice cream? Aside from the lactose intolerant and those who live a vegan lifestyle, of course. One of the best tasting summer treats has always been homemade ice cream. When I was younger, my mother would make ice cream sandwiches for the 4th of July. After our bbq and celebrations were over and the sun had set, we would climb on to the roof of my parents' house (with adult supervision, of course), snuggle on a blanket and watch the fireworks across the bay as we happily noshed on those scrumptious frozen treats.
At the time, my mother had every kitchen gadget known to mankind in the early '90s, so naturally, she had an ice cream maker. Being the poor and underemployed woman I am, I do not have every kitchen gadget known to mankind in the second decade of the new millennium. And while this method of ice cream making is a little time consuming, I promise you, it's worth it. And being the creative ingenue that you all love and adore, I included a couple options to alleviate the time-suck (and cost).
Ingredients
1 star of anise
10 whole cloves
10 whole all spice berries
2 cinnamon sticks
10 whole white peppercorns
2 cardamom pods, opened to seeds
1/4 cup black tea (English Breakfast)
1 cup milk
2 cups of heavy cream (divided in half)
3/4 cup sugar
pinch of salt
6 egg yolks
Directions:
1. Combine 1 cup of milk and spices in a heavy saucepan. Heat until steamy (NOT BOILING) and hot to touch. Lower heat to warm. Cover and let set for 1 hour.
2. Reheat mixture until steamy. Add tea leaves. Remove from heat, stir in tea and let steep for 10 minutes. Use fine mesh strainer to remove tea leaves and spices. Return milk to saucepan. Add sugar and heat, stirring until sugar dissolves.
3. WHILE THE TEA IS STEEPING: Prepare the remaining cup of cream over an ice bath. Pour cream into a medium bowl and set in ice water (LOTS OF ICE) over a larger bowl. Set mesh strainer on top of both bowls, then set aside.
4. Whisk yolks in medium bowl. Slowly pour heated milk into eggs, whisking constantly so eggs don't cook. Scrape back into the saucepan.
5. Return saucepan to stove, stirring constantly over medium heat with a wooden spoon, scraping bottom as you stir, until mix coats spoon (without running), approximately 10 minutes. Remove from heat immediately and pour through mesh strainer over the ice bath.
6. Pour custard through the strainer from Step 2 and stir into the cold cream.
7. Once initially chilled in the ice bath, chill in the refrigerator for several hours.
8. Move the chilled cream from the ice bath to the freezer and allow to set for 20 minutes. Scrape crystals from sides to center, beat mix thoroughly then return to freezer. Allow to set for another 45 minutes, then scrape crystals and beat thoroughly. Repeat over the course of 4 hours. By the end, you should have scraped approximately 4-6 times.
The fun part of actually creating the ice cream sandwiches. When I made them, I used basic chocolate chip cookies, but use your imagination. Go crazy. Spoon the ice cream onto the bottom of one cookie, spread it evenly across, top with another cookie. Make sure you use the flat bottoms of the cookies as the actual sandwich part that will touch the ice cream. It makes assembly without breakage so much easier. Something that you'd think would be a no-brainer, but believe it or not, I have had to explain that little detail before. Wrap thoroughly and tightly in plastic wrap, then freeze overnight. They should be good to go the next day.
Then, just unwrap and enjoy.
QUESTIONS OF THE DAY: Have you made any of our Tasty Tuesday recipes? How did they turn out? Did you make any creative substitutions?
Always remember you can submit your own recipes and we will post them to share. The goal of the Diaries of Eugene is one of community involvement. Pictures of your creations (both culinary and craft) are welcomed and appreciated. You will be given proper credit, I promise.
***You can substitute the spices and tea with a couple tablespoons of vanilla chai mix (conveniently available at your local grocery store or coffee shop).***
***If you have an ice cream maker, congratulations, you're better than me and you can skip a ton of this recipe.***






